Thanks for reading Raising Good Humans on Substack! My first book, The Five Principles of Parenting: Your Essential Guide to Raising Good Humans is now available for purchase here.
Every once in a while I share a guest essay on my Substack. This is from one of my favorite guests on Raising Good Humans Podcast, Dr. Marc Brackett! His new book Dealing With Feeling is out TODAY and you are going to love it! He is also my guest again this week (episode released on Friday!!) and I hope you will tune in to listen.

Personality Isn’t Destiny: Why and How Parents Should Focus on Emotion Regulation
By Marc Brackett, author of the new book, Dealing with Feeling.
Parents often ask me: Is my child’s temperament or their personality destiny? If my baby is shy, will they always struggle socially? If my toddler has big outbursts, will they always be “too sensitive” or “aggressive”?
My answer is: temperament is the starting point, not the endpoint. As you’ve learned from Aliza, children arrive in the world with a biological baseline—some more reactive, some more inhibited, some more easygoing. But those traits are raw material. What truly shapes life outcomes is what we do with that material.
That “what we do” is emotion regulation. It’s the learned set of skills for understanding and managing our feelings—pausing before reacting, naming emotions with accuracy, using strategies like breathing, reframing, or seeking support. In my research and in my new book, Dealing with Feeling, I describe regulation as the bridge: it explains why two children with similar temperaments can develop in very different ways. Strong regulation turns sensitivity into strength.
The Goodness-of-Fit Principle
One of the most powerful ideas parents can embrace is “goodness of fit.” At its core, it’s about helping children learn how to regulate emotions in ways that work with—rather than against—their natural temperament.
If you have a fiery, reactive child, constant reprimands won’t teach emotion regulation; they usually fuel the fire. What helps is modeling calming strategies, validating big feelings, and providing structured ways to to cool down. If you have a conscientious, rule-following child, doubling down on performance pressure undermines healthy regulation. What they need is compassion, reminders that mistakes are normal, and guidance in reframing errors as opportunities to learn.
There isn’t a one-size-fits-all playbook. Two children—even siblings—likely require different parenting approaches. “Good” parenting is not about following a universal formula; it’s about recognizing who your child is, then giving them the skills and support to regulate emotions in a way that helps them thrive.
Every Act of Regulation Shapes Personality
Personality isn’t fixed in stone at birth. It emerges through repeated moments of regulation. Each time a child pauses before reacting, names what they’re feeling, or co-regulates with a parent, they are literally wiring their brain and shaping their personality.
That’s why I say: every time a child manages a feeling, they’re building character. And every time a parent scaffolds that process—by staying calm during a meltdown, by helping label emotions, by modeling self-care—they’re providing the building blocks for resilience, empathy, and wellbeing.
Big Feelings Can Become Big Gifts
Sensitivity is often miscast as weakness. But with emotion regulation, sensitivity can be transformed into empathy, creativity, and even leadership. A child who “feels everything” may become the friend who notices when others are hurting, the artist who captures subtle emotions, the innovator who sees connections others miss. Parents play a crucial role here. Instead of pathologizing big feelings, we can reframe them as big gifts—if we provide the tools and support to channel them productively. Parents should reflect: what implicit messages am I sending about which emotions are acceptable? Which feelings get silenced in my household, and which get celebrated?
The Social Brain: Why Relationships Matter
Emotion regulation is not just a brain skill; it’s a relational one. Children don’t learn to regulate in isolation. First, they co-regulate—borrowing calm from a parent’s steady presence. Over time, through repeated scaffolding, they internalize those skills and self-regulate. Think of it this way: no child learns to ride a bike without someone steadying the seat at first. Emotion Regulation is no different. Our presence, tone of voice, and modeling are the “training wheels” of emotional life.
Adolescence: A Second Window
Parents of teenagers often feel like all their earlier work has unraveled. But adolescence is not a failure; it’s a second window. Because the adolescent brain is still developing, especially in areas linked to self-control, the teen years are a prime time for building regulation skills.
Yes, emotions run high. But that’s exactly why it’s the perfect time to learn. Supportive relationships and continued scaffolding during this stage can pay lifelong dividends.
The Big Five Lens
When it comes to parenting, as we’ve learned, one size rarely fits all. Every child brings their own tendencies into the world—and those differences shape how they experience, express, and regulate emotions. One practical way to make sense of these differences is through the “Big Five” personality traits, a well-researched framework that captures the broad patterns of how people think, feel, and behave.
The Big Five isn’t about labeling kids or boxing them in. It’s about noticing their natural style—whether they’re energetic or reflective, empathetic or strong-willed, perfectionistic or easygoing—and then tailoring your approach to help them build the emotion regulation skills they’ll need most. Some children need more support calming down; others need practice speaking up. Some need to loosen their grip on perfection, while others benefit from strengthening routines and follow-through.
By using the Big Five as a lens, parents can anticipate where challenges may arise and provide targeted support that helps kids not only manage their emotions but use them as tools for growth and resilience.
Here’s how each trait intersects with emotion regulation:
Extraversion–Introversion.
Extraverts: Energetic, outgoing, sometimes impulsive. Need pause-and-think strategies at high-energy moments.
Introverts: Reflective, reserved, easily overstimulated. Need support creating quiet spaces and confidence to re-engage.
Agreeableness–Low Agreeableness
Agreeable kids: Empathetic, cooperative, sometimes conflict-averse. Need help setting boundaries and practicing self-care.
Less agreeable kids: Assertive, direct, sometimes argumentative. Need coaching in empathy and perspective-taking.
Conscientiousness–Low Conscientiousness
Highly conscientious: Organized, disciplined, sometimes perfectionistic. Need reminders that mistakes are learning opportunities.
Less conscientious: Flexible, spontaneous, sometimes careless. Need routines and follow-through to build self-regulation.
Neuroticism (Emotional Stability)
Highly reactive: Sensitive to stress, quick to anger or sadness. Need calming tools and reassurance.
Emotionally stable: Even-keeled, resilient, sometimes dismissive. Need encouragement to notice and name emotions and might get thrown off with strong emotions.
Openness–Low Openness
High openness: Curious, imaginative, emotionally intense. Need channels for creative expression and grounding strategies.
Low openness: Practical, routine-oriented, sometimes rigid. Need encouragement to try new experiences and tolerate uncertainty.
The Takeaway for Parents
You don’t need to “fix” your child’s temperament. You can’t—and you shouldn’t. What you can do is model, guide, and scaffold the skills of regulation. That means managing your own emotions in front of your children, practicing self-care, naming feelings, and creating an environment where emotions are not feared but understood. When you do, you’re not just managing meltdowns or smoothing over conflicts. You’re shaping character. You’re turning raw material into resilience, empathy, and wellbeing.
Temperament sets the stage. Emotion regulation writes the play. That’s the heart of what I explore in my new book, Dealing with Feeling—and why I believe this skill is the difference between simply getting through life and truly thriving. As a parent, educator, or friend, you already know how much it matters. My hope is that learning about emotion regulation gives you the tools not just to cope, but to help yourself and the people you love flourish.
A quick reminder to buy my first book, The Five Principles of Parenting, and write a review from wherever you order. Reviews really help to get the book noticed, and to spread the word. Please especially rate and review any books purchased on Amazon (it shockingly really, really matters!). Also, when you receive the book, snap a quick pic with it and post on social media. Share one thing you love about it and help me to get more copies into the hands of parents in your community. Tell a friend about the book, or about something you found helpful in the book. Parents look to each other for advice, and I’d love to be a part of the support you pass on to your loved ones.




Did you know that your birth order in the family has a powerful impact on shaping your personality? Whether you're the oldest, middle, youngest, or only child, it influences how you see the world and relate to others.
Grandparents can play an important role here too, not just parents, in co-regulating and teaching emotion regulation skills. Especially when one of the parents lacks those skills.