How Many Toys is Too Many?
A Little Science to Guide
Thanks for reading Raising Good Humans on Substack! My first book, The Five Principles of Parenting: Your Essential Guide to Raising Good Humans is now available for purchase here.
Many of our kids have collected a lot of toys. Birthdays, holidays, and those irresistible department store runs can lead to a mountain of playthings. But did you know that having fewer toys might actually be better for your little one's development? Here’s what the research tells us.
The Toy Overload Experiment. Researchers decided to test this idea out. They invited a bunch of toddlers to a play lab and randomly assigned them into two groups. One group got 16 toys, while the other group got 4.
What Happened?
For those with 16 Toys: The toddlers bounced around like pinballs, playing with an average of 8 toys, but not really focusing on any single one.
4 Toys: These toddlers spent way more time with each toy, getting creative and exploring all the different ways to play.
In addition, other studies have shown that shared engagement beats out toys in general, as far as learning and parent-child connection.
The Bottom Line: Less is More. Fewer toys = deeper, more imaginative play. When toddlers aren't overwhelmed by choices, they dive into their toys, developing problem-solving skills and furthering creativity. In addition, shared moments of attention and focus are a better way to invest your time. Remember that anything can be a toy, and that YOU can facilitate play with household objects, your voice, your hands, and simple everyday activities.
Why This Matters
Toddlers are still learning to focus. Too many toys can be distracting, making it hard for them to concentrate and fully engage. Too many toys with only one way to play can even stifle curiosity, and frustrate kids who want to explore pretend play and use their imagination. Too many toys can be the enemy of independent play - leaving you with more “stuff” and a toddler unwilling to give anything a try. Sound familiar? We know.
Independent exploration is a cornerstone of early childhood development, fostering cognitive, emotional, and physical growth. When children engage in self-directed play, they actively make sense of the world around them, experimenting with cause and effect, problem-solving, and decision-making. This type of play allows children to follow their own curiosity, leading to a deeper understanding of their interests and abilities. Moreover, independent exploration nurtures creativity and imagination, as children are free to invent scenarios, roles, and narratives without external constraints. This not only enhances cognitive flexibility, but also builds confidence and a sense of agency. Physically, self-directed play often involves gross and fine motor skills, promoting coordination, balance, and spatial awareness. Socially, even solitary play contributes to emotional regulation and self-awareness, as children learn to manage their feelings and impulses. Ultimately, independent exploration empowers children to become active learners, laying the foundation for a lifetime of curiosity and self-motivation.
Fast Tips for Toy Management
Toy Rotation: Stash some toys away and swap them out every few weeks or months. This keeps things fresh and exciting without the overwhelm.
Quality Over Quantity: Invest in a few open-ended toys (think blocks, dolls, art supplies) that can be played with in many ways.
Declutter: Donate toys that your child has outgrown, or rarely plays with, or save them for another child.
But My Kid Loves All Their Toys!
That's totally normal! You don't have to get rid of everything. The key is to find a balance that works for your child and your home (and you can help them experience the disappointment of having to make the hard choice of letting some go).
Remember, you're the parent. Ultimately, you know your child best. If toy rotation sounds like a headache, skip it! The goal is to create a playful environment that supports your child's development, not add more stress to your life.
A quick reminder to buy my first book, The Five Principles of Parenting, and write a review from wherever you order. Reviews really help to get the book noticed, and to spread the word. Please especially rate and review any books purchased on Amazon (it shockingly really, really matters!). Also, when you receive the book, snap a quick pic with it and post on social media. Share one thing you love about it and help me to get more copies into the hands of parents in your community. Tell a friend about the book, or about something you found helpful in the book. Parents look to each other for advice, and I’d love to be a part of the support you pass on to your loved ones.
Would this apply to books as well?
It's incredible how much more creative kids become when they are given less. I'm a big fan of getting outside and finding natural elements to play with (dirt, sticks, water, sand!). Thank you for sharing!